Matching Old Varnish . Bleaching the wood where varnish has been removed to get it to match areas with old varnish is theoretically possible (i've never been able to do it) but, more work than just. It is okay to put polyurethane over old varnish without ruining the finish. Tips for Matching Wood Floors Home Remodeling Ideas for Basements from www.hgtv.com Varnish has little or no color and has no added pigment as opposed to paint or wood stain which contains pigment. So, let’s discuss each of the following steps one by one to know how to properly stain over varnished wood. Just finished with multiple coats of urethane.